Scenarios & Examples
Scenario 1 — You keep replaying the breakup conversation
What's happening:
You keep replaying the breakup conversation in your mind—what they said, what you said, what you wish you'd said differently. You think if you can just figure out what went wrong, you'll understand and be able to move forward.
But replaying the conversation doesn't help you understand—it keeps you stuck in the past, replaying the same thoughts without new insight. The more you replay, the more urgent it feels, so you replay more.
What helps:
- Write it down, then set it aside: Get the whole conversation out of your head and onto paper, then put it away
- Set a time limit: Give yourself 10 minutes to think about it, then move on
- Interrupt the pattern: When you notice yourself replaying, change your environment or do something different
- Focus on what you can control: You can't change what happened, but you can control how you respond now
- Create a new story: Instead of replaying the old conversation, write a new story about what you're learning
The goal isn't to never think about it—it's to process it instead of getting stuck in it.
Scenario 2 — You keep going over what you did wrong
What it's trying to regulate:
You keep replaying your mistakes, thinking if you can just figure out what you did wrong, you'll understand and be able to fix it or avoid it next time. This feels productive, like you're taking responsibility and learning.
But replaying your mistakes doesn't help you learn—it keeps you stuck in self-blame and prevents you from moving forward. The more you replay, the more you blame yourself, so you replay more.
A replacement behavior:
- Write it down, then reframe: Write what you did wrong, then write what you learned and how you'll do differently
- Practice self-compassion: You made mistakes, but that doesn't make you a bad person. Everyone makes mistakes
- Focus on growth: Instead of replaying what you did wrong, focus on what you're learning and how you're growing
- Get support: Talk to a therapist or friend who can help you see the pattern and break it
- Create new stories: Instead of replaying your mistakes, write stories about your growth and learning
The replacement behavior isn't about avoiding responsibility—it's about learning from mistakes without getting stuck in them.
Scenario 3 — You can't stop thinking about "what if"
Explain pattern:
You keep replaying "what if" scenarios—what if you'd done things differently, what if they'd stayed, what if you'd tried harder. You think if you can just figure out what would have happened, you'll have closure.
But "what if" scenarios are fantasies, not reality. Replaying them doesn't help you understand what happened—it keeps you stuck in possibilities that don't exist. The more you replay, the more real they feel, so you replay more.
Stabilize plan:
- Accept uncertainty: You'll never know what would have happened. That's okay. You don't need to know.
- Focus on what is: Instead of "what if," focus on what actually happened and what you can learn from it
- Set a time limit: Give yourself 10 minutes to think about "what if," then move on
- Practice mindfulness: Notice the "what if" thoughts without getting caught in them
- Create new stories: Instead of replaying "what if," write stories about what you're learning and how you're growing
- Get support: Talk to a therapist or friend who can help you see the pattern and break it
The stabilize plan isn't about eliminating "what if" thoughts—it's about not getting stuck in them.
Scenario 4 — You want to talk to them about it
Relief vs growth framing:
You feel like you need to talk to them about what happened—to explain, to ask questions, to get closure. You think if you can just talk to them, everything will make sense and you'll be able to move forward.
This is relief-seeking, not growth. The conversation might provide temporary relief, but it won't help you process what happened. And having the conversation while you're still replaying often makes things worse.
Growth approach:
- Process on your own first: Write it down, talk to a therapist, journal about what happened. Process it yourself before talking to them
- Wait until you're regulated: Don't have important conversations while you're still replaying. Give yourself time to process first
- Focus on your clarity, not theirs: You can't control their response, but you can control whether you're clear when you talk
- Set boundaries: If they contact you while you're still processing, use a script: "I'm working through some things on my own right now. I'll reach out when I'm ready."
- Notice the difference: When you can talk from a place of clarity rather than replaying, you're more likely to get what you need
Growth means having conversations from clarity, not replaying. Relief means having them to feel better right now.
Scenario 5 — You think you need to understand them
When it helps:
Wanting to understand what happened can help when:
- You're regulated and thinking clearly
- You're seeking understanding, not trying to change their mind
- You're ready to accept whatever answer you get
- You're not using it as a way to maintain contact or hope
In these cases, seeking understanding can provide clarity and help you move forward.
When it harms:
Wanting to understand can harm when:
- You're still replaying and not thinking clearly
- You're hoping understanding will change their mind or bring them back
- You're using it as an excuse to maintain contact
- You're not ready to accept the answer if it's not what you want to hear
- You're seeking relief from uncertainty rather than actual understanding
In these cases, seeking understanding usually makes things worse—it keeps you stuck in replaying, creates false hope, or confirms what you already know but aren't ready to accept.
What to do instead:
- Process on your own first: Write it down, talk to a therapist, journal about what you need to understand. Often, you can find understanding without them
- Accept that some things don't have answers: Not every relationship ends with clear answers. Sometimes understanding comes from accepting that
- Focus on your understanding, not theirs: Understanding yourself is more valuable than understanding them
- Wait until you're clear: If you still want to understand after you've processed on your own, then consider seeking it. But if you're asking because replaying makes you feel like you need to know right now, wait
Related reading
